To see entire article click here

Joseph Phelps 2004 Insignia (Napa Valley)
Score: 97 points

(February 2008) This is a magnificiently structured young wine reminiscent of a fine young Pauillac. Best after 2012, and should have another decade after that, at least. Cellar Selection. - S.H.

Joseph Phelps 2004 Backus Cabernet Sauvignon (Oakville)
Score: 95 points

(February 2008) It's impossible for a Cabernet to be richer, more opulent or more hedonistically stunning on opening than this beauty from veteran Phelps. Absolutely gorgeous now, with immaculate elegance.

California's Best of 2007

Joseph Phelps 2004 Insignia - Napa Valley
Propriety Blend of the Year

(Dec/Jan 2007-08)… the wine exhibits a deep core of luscious blackberry-blueberry fruit enhanced by seductive, fruitcake-like spicy notes and subtle vanillin oak. Finishes long and graceful.

California's Best of 2007

Joseph Phelps 2004 Backus Vineyard - Oakville
Cabernet Sauvignon of the Year

(Dec/Jan 2007-08) Intense and powerful, yet at the same time elegant and focused, the wine's concentration and depth of flavor are amazing. Forward aromas exude a melange of black fruit ...broadened by fruitcake spices and dark chocolate.